Hydroponic Hurdles: What Plants Don’t Do Well in Hydroponics? (2023)


I’ve learned the hard way that not all plants are cut out for hydroponics. It turns out, some just don’t thrive in a soil-less environment.

From space-hogging plants that quickly outgrow hydro systems to thirsty crops that drain nutrient reserves, there are hurdles we need to be aware of. (1)

And let’s not forget those unanchored and unstable ones that require soil for support or the picky ones that rely on insect pollination.

Luckily, I’ve got some well-suited replacements up my sleeve.

So join me as we explore the world of hydroponic hurdles and discover how to save our sanity in the process.


What Plants Don’t Do Well in Hydroponics?

Plants that have deep root systems or large root structures, such as oak trees or large bushes, don’t typically fare well in hydroponic systems due to space constraints. Additionally, plants that rely on mycorrhizal relationships with soil fungi may struggle in hydroponics, as these beneficial fungi are absent in hydroponic setups.

Not All Plants are Created Equal: Which Ones to Avoid for Hydroponics

You shouldn’t try growing plants like corn or sunflowers in hydroponics because they don’t thrive as well without soil. While hydroponics is an excellent method for growing a wide variety of plants, some types are better suited for traditional soil-based gardening.

One category of plants that may not perform optimally in hydroponic systems is root crops or root vegetables. These include vegetables such as carrots, potatoes, and beets, which rely on the nutrients found in the soil to develop their underground tubers or bulbs.

Another group of plants that may not be suitable for hydroponics are pole beans. These climbing beans require extensive space and support to grow properly due to their vine-like nature. In a limited-space hydro system, it can be challenging to provide the necessary vertical structure for pole beans to thrive.

Additionally, fruit trees like fig trees may pose challenges when grown in hydroponics. Fruit trees have deep-rooted systems that anchor them into the ground and allow them access to nutrients from the surrounding soil. Without this connection, it can be difficult for fruit trees to establish themselves and produce healthy yields.

Now let’s move on to discussing another type of plant that presents challenges in hydroponic systems: space hogs – large plants that quickly outgrow hydro systems.

Space Hogs: Large Plants That Quickly Outgrow Hydro Systems

Growing large plants in hydro systems can quickly become a challenge due to their fast growth rate. Hydroponic systems, which rely on nutrient-rich water instead of soil, provide an optimal environment for plant growth. However, when it comes to accommodating the root systems of larger plants, hydro systems may fall short.

Large plants require ample space for their roots to spread and access nutrients. In traditional soil gardening, this is not an issue as the roots can penetrate deep into the ground. But in hydroponics, where plants are grown in containers or channels with limited space, root expansion becomes a limiting factor.

Some examples of large plants that may outgrow hydro systems include tomatoes, cucumbers, melons, and pumpkins. These plants have vigorous growth patterns and extensive root systems that need room to thrive. Without adequate space for their roots to grow and access nutrients efficiently, these plants may experience stunted growth or nutrient deficiencies.

To overcome this challenge, gardeners utilizing hydroponic systems must carefully select appropriate plant varieties or consider alternative growing techniques such as vertical farming or aquaponics. These methods allow for better utilization of available space and provide additional support structures for larger plants.

Hungry Crops: Extra Thirsty Plants That Drain Nutrient Reserves

Some crops in hydro systems can be particularly thirsty, depleting nutrient reserves more rapidly than others. Leafy greens, such as lettuce and spinach, are prime examples of plants that require a significant amount of water to thrive. Hydroponic gardening provides a controlled environment where plants receive water directly to their roots, allowing for optimal nutrient absorption. However, the constant supply of nutrient-rich water can lead to faster depletion of nutrients compared to traditional soil-based cultivation.

To prevent nutrient deficiency in these extra thirsty plants, it is important to closely monitor the nutrient levels in the hydroponic system and adjust accordingly. Regular testing and adjustments are necessary to maintain the proper balance needed for healthy plant growth. Additionally, choosing plant types that are better suited for hydroponics can help minimize potential problems with nutrient depletion.

Transitioning into the next section about ‘unanchored and unstable’ plants that require soil for support: While some crops thrive in hydroponic systems, there are certain plant types that simply do not fare well without soil as a means of support.

Unanchored and Unstable: Plants That Require Soil for Support

Transitioning into the next section about ‘unanchored and unstable’ plants that require soil for support:

There are certain plant types that simply don’t fare well without soil as a means of support in hydroponic systems. While hydroponic growing offers numerous benefits, such as increased yield and reduced water usage, it may not be suitable for all plants.

Soil plants, or those that have evolved to rely on the physical support provided by soil, can struggle in hydroponics. These plants have long roots that penetrate deep into the ground, anchoring them securely. Without soil, they lack the stability they need to grow effectively.

Some examples of these unanchored and unstable plants include large fruiting crops like tomatoes and cucumbers. These varieties typically require trellises or cages to support their weight when grown in traditional gardens. In hydroponics, finding an alternative method to provide adequate support can be challenging.

Other types of plants that may struggle without soil support are tall and leggy plants like sunflowers or corn. Their height makes them more susceptible to toppling over in a system without the natural stability of soil.

When considering which plants to grow in your hydroponic setup, it’s crucial to choose ones suited for this type of cultivation method. Opting for compact varieties or those specifically bred for hydroponics can help ensure success with your system.

Pollination Problems: Plants That Require Insect Pollination

To ensure successful pollination in your setup, it’s important to consider the specific plant types that rely on insect pollinators for reproduction. While many hydroponic plants can self-pollinate or rely on wind for pollination, there are certain crops, like beans and some vegetables, that require the assistance of insects.

In a hydroponic system where there are no natural insect visitors, this can pose a challenge. Beans, for example, have flowers that need to be visited by bees or other pollinators to transfer pollen from the male stamen to the female stigma. Without these visits, bean plants may fail to produce fruits or have poor yields. Similarly, vegetables like cucumbers and squash also benefit greatly from insect pollination.

If you’re determined to grow these types of plants in a hydroponic setup without relying on insects, you may need to explore alternative methods such as hand-pollination using a small brush or shaking the flowers gently to release pollen.

However, if you’re looking for easier options that don’t require extra effort or intervention, there are better bets: well-suited replacements for finicky hydroponic plants that don’t rely heavily on insect pollination.

Better Bets: Well-Suited Replacements for Finicky Hydroponic Plants

If you’re looking for easier options, there are better bets for well-suited replacements of finicky hydroponic plants that don’t rely heavily on insect pollination. Hydroponic growers often face challenges when it comes to finding the right type of plant for their hydroponic garden.

While some plants thrive in a hydroponic system, others may struggle to adapt. One option for hydroponic growers is to focus on plants that self-pollinate or do not require insect pollination. These types of plants can be a healthier choice for hydroponics, as they can grow and produce fruits without relying on external factors like insects.

Commercial growers have found success with plants such as lettuce, herbs like basil and parsley, and microgreens in their hydroponic gardens. These crops are well-suited for hydroponics because they can easily self-pollinate or do not require extensive pollination efforts.

By choosing these alternative plants, hydroponic growers can ensure healthy plants and successful yields in their systems. It’s important to consider the specific requirements of each plant and provide the necessary nutrients and conditions for optimal growth.

With careful selection and proper care, growing these replacement crops can be a rewarding experience for commercial hydroponic growers.

Saving Your Sanity: Steering Clear of Problematic Hydroponic Plants

Steering clear of problematic hydroponic plants can save your sanity and ensure a smoother growing experience. Here are three common vegetables that may cause root or nutrient issues in hydroponics:

  1. Carrots: While carrots are a popular vegetable, they require deep soil for proper root development. In hydroponics, the limited space can hinder their growth, resulting in stunted or misshapen roots.
  2. Tomatoes: Although tomatoes can be grown successfully in hydroponics, they are prone to several nutrient deficiencies such as calcium and magnesium. These deficiencies can lead to blossom end rot and affect fruit quality.
  3. Cabbage: Leafy plants like cabbage often struggle in hydroponic systems due to their larger size and need for ample space to grow. Without enough room, the leaves may become crowded and provide an environment conducive to disease development.

It’s important to note that not all plants thrive in hydroponics, but there are plenty of other options available that are well-suited for this cultivation method. By choosing suitable plants and avoiding those prone to root issues or nutrient deficiencies, you can maximize your success and minimize frustration with your hydroponic garden.


In conclusion, it’s important to remember that not all plants thrive in hydroponic systems. Space-hogging plants like pumpkins and watermelons can quickly outgrow the setup, causing overcrowding issues. Additionally, thirsty crops such as corn and celery can deplete nutrient reserves faster than they can be replenished.

Moreover, plants that require soil for support, like sunflowers and tomatoes, may struggle in hydroponics without proper anchoring. Lastly, insect-pollinated plants like cucumbers and squash may face pollination challenges in a controlled environment.

By choosing well-suited replacements for these finicky plants, we can ensure a successful and fruitful hydroponic garden. Did you know that some hydroponic lettuce varieties can grow up to 1 inch per day? Just imagine the lush greenery filling your space!

Was this helpful?